Revista Multidisciplinaria Perspectivas Investigativas
Multidisciplinary Journal Investigative Perspectives
Vol. 5(2), 1-10, 2025
Identidad cultural en escolares colombianos
Cultural identity in Colombian schoolchildren
Gustavo Adolfo Jarava-Acosta
2
INTRODUCTION
Cultural identity is one of the fundamental pillars in the process of personal development and
citizenship, with greater incidence in social contexts characterised by ethnic and cultural
diversity, as in the case of Colombia, the school must transcend the simple transmission of
knowledge, being, therefore, a privileged place for the establishment of processes that build
belonging and the reaffirmation of identity (Cintora, 2011; Herrera, Díaz & Suaza, 2003).
In the Colombian scenario, which reveals a historical heritage in the shadow of colonisation,
forced displacement and the mixing of cultures such as Afro-descendant, indigenous and
mestizo, it is necessary to investigate how the formal education process impacts on the process
of constructing cultural identity in students. Thus, textbooks, pedagogical discourses and
curricular practices can either promote inclusion or reproduce mechanisms of exclusion and
segregation (Castillo, 2009; Tenorio, 2011); numerous studies demonstrate this (many of which
share an analytical framework developed by US scholar Christine Sleeter, who, along with
others, also clarified how discourses and guidance of multicultural education have permeated
the educational landscape, but have still developed alongside the maintenance and
legitimisation of racism).
Therefore, this literature review aims to reveal important aspects present in the studies and to
point out guidelines for reshaping more inclusive educational practices with a plural cultural
identity. The relevance of the study around cultural identity within the academic environment
comes not only from its relationship with educational performance and social cohesion, but also
from the possibility of impacting on the construction of citizenship and the transformation of
realities of historical marginalisation (García, 2003; Rojas & Araque, 2021).
The review of empirical and theoretical studies allows us to recognise specific tensions between
hegemonic discourses and strategies of resistance that appear in contexts of cultural diversity.
In this way, the need has been realised to show critical perspectives that problematise the
processes of "normalisation" of certain knowledge and, at the same time, to show strategies that
make it possible to integrate diverse perspectives into the school curriculum (Hurtado &
Castellanos, 2020; Giraldo & Taborda, 2020).
This review is based on literature that critically examines, in various ways, how the "other" is
represented in textbooks and pedagogical discourses, as exemplified by Almeida & Ramírez
(2011) who show how textbook illustrations can reproduce stereotypes and reductionist views
that students have of Afro-Colombians, while studies such as Arroyo & Agurto (2021) advocate
the need to move towards didactic strategies that strengthen a true and plural cultural identity.
Similarly, other authors have used the concept of cultural identity construction in pedagogical
interaction with family and community (Rodríguez-Cruz, 2020; Pincheira-Muñoz, 2021).
Therefore, in the first place, this literature review is fundamental to enter into the knowledge
already generated on the construction of cultural identity in Colombian schoolchildren,
identifying in turn the strengths and limitations of the way in which this topic has been treated in
the research reviewed. Thus, this article seeks to: a) describe the conceptual and empirical
overview of how cultural identity is framed in the school environment, b) characterise the
methodologies used in the studies reviewed, and c) analyse the pedagogical implications
derived from these studies for education in Colombia.
Therefore, it becomes essential to be part of the discussion on what it means to be inclusive
and how cultural diversity should also be part of the educational programme. As education
policies have alternated between homogenisation and recognition of diversity, it is necessary to
analyse the construction of discourses that shape students' cultural identity. These discourses
have evolved around the world to respond to new challenges, especially in the context of
globalisation and the prevalent interdependence of educational processes globally, including
that of migration, digitalisation and multiculturalism (Rodríguez, Cruz, Naranjo & Torres, 2020;
Subero & Esteban-Guitart, 2020).
This indicates the need for a reconceptualisation of pedagogical practice, integrating traditional
knowledge and intercultural dialogue as a means to strengthen a rich and diverse cultural
identity (Leiva-Miranda, Rambaud-Almanza & González-Arismendi, 2024). Thus, it emphasises